What went wrong with economics?

The credit crunch has led to rethinking of and debate on sophisticated financial instruments and also some of the fiercely defended economic models. A couple of months ago, The Economist discussed what went wrong with economics and the debate on the foundations of financial economics and also on the efficient-markets hypothesis.

Now, Paul Krugman (2008 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Science) has written an op-ed in the NYT about how economists got it wrong. Krugman blames an over emphasis on 'all-encompassing, intellectually elegant' mathematical approach which ignores many complexities. He also criticizes taking Friedman's push for monetarism (which asserts that a very limited form of government intervention is sufficient.) too far. The efficient market hypothesis is also criticized. Krugman captures the tension between macroeconomists i.e between 'fresh water' purists versus 'salt water' pragmatists.

So what are the suggestions? Krugman suggests a further look into behavioral finance and behavorial economics. Moreover, he feels that the Keynesian approach needs to be re-embraced 'for making sense of recessions and depressions'. Finally he want economists to 'incorporate the realities of finance into macroeconomics'.

And now another take on the same topic.


(Cartoon taken from NYT: http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2009/09/06/magazine/06economic.8-650.jpg)


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Smart Lotteries in School Choice Ex-ante Pareto-Improvement with Ex-post Stability

Fair budgets from ranked ballots: PB-EAR

Proportionally Representative Clustering