Approximating Random Serial Dictatorship: Hardness and Markov Chains
Haris Aziz, Bart de Keijzer, Sebastian Homrighausen, Ali Pourmiri: A pproximating Random Serial Dictatorship: Hardness and Markov Chains . Working Paper, 202 6 Abstract: We consider a setting in which a randomised social choice rule selects one of the alternatives on the basis of preferences expressed by agents. Our focus is on \emph{Random Serial Dictatorship} (RSD), a central rule in social choice theory. Computing RSD shares exactly is known to be $\mathsf{\#P}$-complete but the complexity of approximating it has been open for more than a decade. We resolve this question negatively: unless $\mathrm{NP}\subseteq\mathrm{BPP}$, there is no FPRAS for computing the RSD share of a given listed alternative, even for dichotomous preferences. We also develop a Markov Chain Monte Carlo framework for approximately counting the permutations that select a target alternative. The framework gives an FPRAS whenever the relevant suffix-restricted state spaces admit rapidly mix...